Over 1000 Pembrokeshire County Council staff face pay cuts as part of controversial wage review (From Western Telegraph)
Get involved: send your pictures, video, news and views by texting WT NEWS to 80360, or email
us
Some Pembrokeshire County Council staff face cuts of up to £5000
1:30pm Friday 8th February 2013 in News By Katy Woodhouse
More than 1,000 Pembrokeshire County Council staff are facing pay cuts as the authority pushes through hugely controversial changes to wages.
Some staff are said to be losing up to £5,000.
PCC has been undertaking a pay and grading review to address "longstanding issues" relating to pay and inequality along with other local authorities.
The union Unison has been encouraging members not to sign up to the new pay, terms and conditions.
But this leaves staff in a difficult position as their right to any hardship entitlement or back pay would be withdrawn if they have not signed by the end of the month, the union added.
Unison Pembrokeshire branch chairman Janet Wyer said more than 1,000 members would be losing out.
"The average is about £2,000, but some people are taking a £5,000 cut and most are at the lower paid end.
"This is affecting people's lives, the impact on their mental health is massive.
"The trade union feels that the council could have negotiated a fairer and better model with less impact at the lower grades of pay," she added.
One worker, who asked not to be identified, is facing a cut of 25% in her wage - around £5,500 full time equivalent - taking her job grading to a level comparable to when she started work more than 10 years ago.
The worker, a single mother, said: "Devastation isn't the word.
"The stress and worry has been hanging over us for months and we're still expected to do our jobs. The lower paid are getting the cuts while the higher paid are getting the rises.
"I do fear for my future financial situation and for my daughter, if I didn't work she wouldn't be able to have swimming lessons or her gymnastics. I just managed to get by before, with extra hours, it makes me angry, I know I'm not the only single parent struggling.
"I'd probably get paid more on benefits and that's really sad to say, I don't want to live off benefits."
Unison said that the authority had "failed to engage in genuine joint working with the trade unions".
Branch secretary Vic Dennis added: "We have been inundated with queries from members some of whom are not sure how they will cope such is the reduction of income. The branch has also had queries from members where both the main earners are suffering big reductions in their pay, many are concerned they will not be able meet their household costs in future."
Council: 'We have fully consulted with unions"
Pembrokeshire County Council said that it had been working on the review for a long period and the trade unions had been "fully consulted with'.
A spokesman added that the nation agreement between the local government employers and trades unions requires every council to review its pay structure for employees covered by the National Joint Council for Local Government Services.
"The changes are necessary to address long standing issues of pay inequality within the authority's workforce - to ensure equal pay for work of equal value.
"As a result of the review, 65.9% of jobs are staying at the same level of pay; 18.3% will be paid more and 15.8% will be paid less," he added.
He said that the chief executive and directors have had a pay freeze since April 2008, and all other senior staff since April 2009.
"The council is committed to doing all it can to assist employees whose jobs are subject to pay reduction.
"These measures include an appeals process to enable employees to challenge grading decision and a compensation allowance scheme which will pay a one-off lump sum of up to £5,500 for those employees who suffer a pay reduction," added the spokesman.
For more information see www.pembrokeshire.gov.uk/payreview
Comments(19)
PCC Weasel
says...
7:51pm Fri 8 Feb 13
Interestingly the PCC spokesman did not mention that all staff have had a pay freeze, not just the chief executive and directors, and also he failed to mention the 7% pay rise the chief officers are giving themselves this year!
It is also pertinent that staff are losing car allowances whilst still being contractually obliged to provide a car at their own expense for council duties whilst those same chief officers will retain their free cars!
As a further insult whilst the chief officers continue on their gravy train, a number of staff have this week been given notice that their are to be made redundant. All without any of our elected councillors even being informed.
Thinking...
says...
11:10pm Fri 8 Feb 13
Indeview J Hudson
says...
9:20am Sat 9 Feb 13
We taxpayers have been told, over the years, about the efficient, lean, management structure the Council operates.
Next years budget allows for a projected saving of some £400,000 from vacancy management.
Staffing matters are for senior managment, they are not withing the remit of councillors to interfere with.
The projected cuts of £1.6m next year are going to affect our services in a ways that have not been explained or identified, from a base supported by a consistent lowest council tax in Wales.
Kiwitaff
says...
12:36am Sun 10 Feb 13
Given all of the adverse publicity regarding serious shortcomings and the necessity for external government agencies needing to be called in to rectify issues. Are Pembrokeshire ratepayers getting value for money from the highest paid senior employee?
PCC Weasel
says...
10:56am Sun 10 Feb 13
Kiwitaff wrote:I am sure the CEO actually believes he is underpaid. A source very close to the heart of the Kremlin tells me that Directors offered to take a 10k pay cut "in sympathy" with the lower paid staff who are getting such huge pay cuts and redundancies.
The CEO Parry Jones was reported as having an annual salary in excess of One Hundred and Ninety Thousand pounds. He will have been in Post for seventeen years in April. Assuming an annual average salary of a mere 150,000 pounds multiplied by 17 represents 2.55 million pounds income over that period.
Given all of the adverse publicity regarding serious shortcomings and the necessity for external government agencies needing to be called in to rectify issues. Are Pembrokeshire ratepayers getting value for money from the highest paid senior employee?
The CEO responded that this was "not an option" and that they were to "forget they had had that conversation".
Read into that what you will!
Get a grip
says...
10:10pm Sun 10 Feb 13
timerousbeastie
says...
12:31am Mon 11 Feb 13
Get a grip wrote:Perhaps you might want to provide some sort of reasoned justification for this assertion?
Most are overpaid and should be sacked
Tttoommy
says...
5:40pm Tue 12 Feb 13
Seriously If he became a public"servant" hoping to change things for the best he would have resigned years ago in shame at his failures
timerousbeastie
says...
6:02pm Tue 12 Feb 13
sarah7776
says...
6:24pm Tue 12 Feb 13
timerousbeastie wrote:I agree that there should be on-topic comments, but I do feel that the comments regarding BJP and other senior managers are on-topic as it is a comparison between what the 'management' are paying themselves while reducing the salaries of a minority (about 16% of the jobs within the grading review) many of whom are coal-face employees.
The article was about 1000 employees, many earning less than £20k receiving cuts of up to £5k. Most of the comments however are about the remuneration of the Chief Executive. It would be nice to see more on-topic comments.
keithg1605
says...
8:18pm Tue 12 Feb 13
Kiwitaff
says...
12:28am Wed 13 Feb 13
The Ratepayers, PCC employees and the elected members deserve a Chief Officer who is prepared to respond publicly to the serious educational issues that have tainted the good name of Pembrokeshire.
Flashbang
says...
12:49am Wed 13 Feb 13
Tina2
says...
6:48am Wed 13 Feb 13
Flashbang wrote:But you are talking about a good boss this is not the case here.
Timerous beastie, it's long been on these pages about the incompetence of the executive running this county. What people are asking is why are the execs are paying themselves more and the workforce less. A good boss would lead by example and take a pay cut too.
timerousbeastie
says...
10:13am Wed 13 Feb 13
Kiwitaff wrote:Hello Kiwi taking your second point first there is no disagreement from me save to say elected members have the power to act, but choose not to, these are the people those of us living in Pemrokeshire elect and ultimately should be expected to act.
Wee timourous beastee private businesses that underperform or cannot effectively manage their budgets get rid of the CEO. In the Public Sector the reverse seems to apply and there would appear to be a lack of accountablity as 1000 staff face a significant wage cut.
The Ratepayers, PCC employees and the elected members deserve a Chief Officer who is prepared to respond publicly to the serious educational issues that have tainted the good name of Pembrokeshire.
Regarding your first point,it is interesting you feel that the "private" sector is somehow a self regulating
meritocracy when it comes to dealing with under performing CEOs maybe you should have a closer look at the banking industry or the history of the recently bankrupt high street retail chains.
The issue here is that 1000 modestly paid individuals are facing a substantial cut to salary after a 3 year freeze (11% real term cut). This will have a significant impact on their families and a knock on effect to the Pembrokeshire economy.
Kiwitaff
says...
10:28pm Wed 13 Feb 13
"The issue here is that 1000 modestly paid individuals are facing a substantial cut to salary after a 3 year freeze (11% real term cut). This will have a significant impact on their families and a knock on effect to the Pembrokeshire economy."
I couldn't agree more. A 1000 people deserve a living wage to provide a stable economy in Pembrokeshire. Elected members should be proactive and re-organise the Senior management structure. I'm sure they could probably all have a reasonable lifestyle on 100k salaries.
ladybench
says...
4:03pm Thu 14 Feb 13
Struggling on
says...
5:45pm Sat 16 Feb 13
Tina2 says...
4:01pm Fri 8 Feb 13
Is this legal?
'He said that the chief executive and directors have had a pay freeze since April 2008,'
A pay freeze wouldn't bother me if I was earning over a £100,000 a year.